Welcome!
E.A.9.11
About This Group
Started on March 5, 2002
Ended on March 27, 2002
22 members, 349 messages

Featured Discussions:
How 9.11 Changed My       Life
Appreciating E.A.9.11
Can War End Terrorism?
Is Patriotism Patriotic?
[Read More...]


 
> About E.A.9.11
> Resources
> Press
> Shout Outs
> The Team
> FAQ
> Get Started
> Contact Us
 


God in school? (messages 1-7)  
Previous Next All messages Group Home

Locke  07:29pm Mar 15, 2002 EST 1 of 7
Hey all,

Out here they are about to pass legislation that will allow schools to post "In God We Trust" on the walls. They are also working on legislation to allow them to post the ten commandments.

Now, I personally feel that "In God We Trust" is fine to post in schools. Like I said in a previous post, I believe in one god with many faces. So saying "In God We Trust" will reflect everyone's God...

Besides, just because some kid sees a sign that says, "Thou shalt not steal" doesn't mean he won't go grab another kids lunch money.

However, I think posting the Ten Commandments goes to far. If we post them shouldn't we post entries from the book of shadows, qoutes from the Koran, maybe the LDS articles of faith, etc. etc.

I think posting the ten commandments puts to much emphasis on the christian religion and treads on non-christian beliefs. What do ya' all think?

..punch and pie


eastendbeachbum  08:52am Mar 17, 2002 EST 2 of 7
I agree in the whole "In God We Trust" qoute. Punch and pie, I think you hit the nail on the head when you said that it reflects everyone's beliefs. That said, the Ten Commandments are absolutly a part of Christian dogma. Myself being a Lutheran, they're a part of my belief system. I don't think it's fair, however to post my beliefs on a wall. I mean, I don't try and oppress people with Christianity. Furthermore, I don'[t think any state legislation has the right to do so, either. In short, 10 Commandments (NO), In God We Trust (yes).

jackY


meggem15  09:20am Mar 17, 2002 EST 3 of 7
I agree with both of you. We should not have actual belief (ie Ten Commandments) in school but I believe mentioning G-d in school is fine.

brassylass  01:08pm Mar 17, 2002 EST 4 of 7
umm...I still dont want in god we trust on the walls because not everyone bleives in one god or any god at all. Not all religions have "god".

BrooklynGirl  08:23pm Mar 18, 2002 EST 5 of 7
I definitely don't think that the Ten Commandments should be posted in schools...that would open up too much controversy. Schools would have to find the "list of beliefs" for every religion or there would be an uproar. I know in my school, there would be a big problem because kids of many different religions attend my school.
As for the "In God We Trust," that's a double-edged sword. While the big religions all believe in God, there are other obscure religions or even better known religions, such as Buddhism, that believe in many gods or Native American religions that belief in nature.

futurepres2  10:20pm Mar 19, 2002 EST 6 of 7
Dear board,

I believe that God needs to be put back in schools nationwide, and a county near me has already done so by placing the Ten Commandments in every classroom. People use the American money, which says "In God We Trust, " so why is it such a big deal?? No one gets offended from that and everyone uses it practically every second. Eventhough America does welcome other religions, America is clearly built on Christianity, which is the Christian religion, founded on the life and teachings of Jesus. So my point is, if we can put "In God We Trust," on money, why not in schools or other public places??

See ya,

Josh


zion613  10:53pm Mar 19, 2002 EST 7 of 7
I totally agree that putting "In G-d* we trust" on the walls of schools is a very good thing. However, I also believe that the Ten Commandments have a place there, as well.

America was founded on the Judeo-Christian belief system, and it has been integrated as an important part of American government, law, and culture. I don't believe in advocating one religion over another - as a Jew, I know how being missionized to feels (not good). I do, though, believe that schools funded by the American government with monies from American taxpaying citizens should espouse American ideals and teach American culture. There is nothing wrong with being patriotic.

*As a Jew, I am forbidden to write out G-d's full name.


Copyright 2002, Global Kids, Inc. | Privacy Policy
Small Group Dialogue software from Web Lab